Challenging an unfair will
When can I challenge a will or distribution of an estate?
The law normally says that people are free to decide how their property should be shared out after they have died, including who to include or exclude as beneficiaries.
The court will not usually interfere with the terms of a will, or (if there is no will) the distribution under the Administration Act 1903 (WA), simply if you:
- did not receive as much as other beneficiaries,
- think you should have received a greater share of an inheritance, or
- are unhappy that other family members were included in the will or distribution.
However, the law recognises that a role of a will or inheritance is to assist the deceased's surviving family members. The court can make adjustments to how an estate is shared out if the will or distribution does not make 'adequate provision for the proper maintenance, support, education or advancement in life' of a family member.
Who can apply?
The Family Provision Act 1972 (WA) sets out who can apply to the Supreme Court to ask for a larger share of an estate. This includes the deceased's:
- married or de facto partner
- former married or de facto partner if they were receiving (or entitled to) maintenance from the deceased
- step-children (in some circumstances)
- grandchildren (in some circumstances), and
- the deceased's parents.
You should get legal advice to confirm you are eligible if you think you may be able to make an application against the estate.
When can you apply?
You must apply to the Supreme Court within six months of the:
- grant of probate (if there was a will), or
- grant of letters of administration (if the deceased did not leave a will).
This time limit may be extended in some circumstances, but extensions are rare. Every effort should be made to apply within the time limit.
If you are outside the time limit, get legal advice as soon as possible.
What will the court consider?
The applicant will have to prove:
- their relationship to the deceased
- why they are entitled to a share (or a larger share) of the property
- why the will (or distribution if there isn't a will) does not properly provide for their future needs.
It is for the court to decide whether or not it will interfere. There are no automatic assumptions that all children should receive an equal share or how property should be divided under a will.
The court will take a number of things into account, including:
- how any change to the share of the estate could affect other beneficiaries
- the sort of property involved and its value
- the ages of the surviving dependants
- the relationship to the deceased of other dependants
- the needs of other dependants and your needs
- the way you acted towards the deceased during their life and your relationship in general.
Applying for a larger share of an inheritance or estate is a complicated process and area of the law. You will need legal advice and help from a lawyer to give you the best chance of success.
Legal Aid WA does not give advice in inheritance matters.
The Law Society of WA can help you find a private lawyer who specialises in this area.
Reviewed: 4 October 2022